Is Tungsten Carbide The Same As Tungsten?
In the materials industry, tiny variations in naming can frequently cause significant confusion. When metal or alloy products are selected by a large number of individuals, a perplexing issue often arises: Tungsten carbide is tungsten – the same thing? Their names appear to be alike and their areas of application also overlap, thus the very first impression they create does not seem to be very different. Nevertheless, if someone hastily considers the two as one, it is highly possible that the wrong materials would be ordered, leading to product performance not reaching the anticipated levels.
To clarify this matter completely, it is necessary to begin with the most basic question: Are they the same? If the answer is negative, then where do the differences lie? Are there any similarities at all?
Table of Contents
Is Tungsten Carbide The Same As Tungsten?
The answer is clear: They are different.
Tungsten is a metallic element with the chemical symbol W and is one of the most heat-resistant metals in nature. tungsten carbide, on the other hand, is a hard alloy formed by sintering carbides formed by the combination of tungsten and carbon with the addition of binders (such as metallic cobalt).
It can be understood in this way: Tungsten is the raw material, while tungsten carbide is the alloy product after technological transformation. They are closely related, but they are completely different in composition and characteristics.
What Are The Differences Between Tungsten And Tungsten Carbide?
- Along with the differences in ingredients
Tungsten: It is one metallic element.
Tungsten Carbide: Tungsten carbide (WC) is the primary component while metal binders are added in small amounts for better balance of strength and toughness.
- Differing performance
The properties of tungsten: Its melting point is recorded at 3422℃ making it one of the metals with the highest melting point in the earth’s crust. It also has very high density, being almost as dense as gold and platinum, that is why it has a very significant advantage in high-temperature and high-density environments. However, tungsten is very brittle and not appropriate for use in parts that are subjected to multiple impacts.
The properties of tungsten carbide: The hardness of tungsten carbide is on par with that of diamond and is way beyond that of most metals. Its wear resistance and compressive strength are fabulously strong and it can take long friction and impact. However, its melting point is a little lower than that of pure tungsten and its density is also a little lower.
- Differences in applications
Tungsten applications: These consist of usage in producing filaments, electrodes, radiation protection materials, high-temperature alloys.
Applications of tungsten carbide: cutting tools, drill bits, molds, wear-resistant parts, and even in the jewelry industry, it is common, such as tungsten carbide rings.
The Similarities Between Tungsten And Tungsten Carbide
Since the differences are so significant, then why are they often confused? This is because they do indeed have some similarities.
- All contain tungsten: The proportion of tungsten in tungsten carbide is usually over 80%, so many people subconsciously think that “tungsten carbide is tungsten”.
- Both are renowned for their hardness and durability: the high density and corrosion resistance of tungsten, as well as the ultra-high hardness and wear resistance of tungsten carbide, are all uniformly promoted as “hard and durable”.
- All can adapt to extreme environments: whether it’s high temperatures or strong impacts, they can all play a role in different situations, just in different ways.
Why Are They So Easily Confused?
There are mainly three reasons:
- Similar names: Whether in English or Chinese, both names contain the character “tungsten”, making it easy for people to think that they are just different names.
- Ambiguous promotion: Marketing often highlights the common points such as “high hardness” and “wear resistance”, but fails to explain the differences in their composition and performance.
- Insufficient user awareness: Ordinary consumers have limited knowledge of materials science and can only make judgments based on names, which leads to misunderstandings.
How To Avoid Choosing The Wrong Materials?
If you are considering purchasing or applying tungsten or tungsten carbide products, you can make a judgment from the following points:
Clarify the requirements
- If what you need is high density and high-temperature resistance, such as radiation shielding or high-temperature environments → choose tungsten.
- If what you need are hardness and wear resistance, such as for cutting tools, molds, and jewelry → choose tungsten carbide.
View the supplier description
- High-quality suppliers will clearly indicate whether it is pure tungsten material or hard alloy.
- If only “tungsten products” are written, the specific material needs to be further confirmed.
Avoid common misunderstandings
- The tungsten carbide rings commonly seen in the market are not pure tungsten but tungsten carbide alloy products. Pure tungsten rings are actually rare because pure tungsten is too brittle and not suitable as jewelry.
By clarifying demands and carefully discriminating, one can avoid purchasing the wrong product due to confusion.
Side-by-Side Technical Comparison: Tungsten vs Tungsten Carbide
Although tungsten and tungsten carbide share the same base element, their physical and mechanical properties are very different. The table below highlights the key distinctions engineers and buyers should understand:
| Property | Tungsten (W) | Tungsten Carbide (WC) |
|---|---|---|
| Material Type | Pure chemical element | Compound of tungsten and carbon |
| Hardness (Mohs) | ~7.5–8 | ~9.0–9.5 (much harder) |
| Density | ~19.3 g/cm³ | ~15.6 g/cm³ |
| Melting Point | ~3422°C | ~2870°C |
| Wear Resistance | Moderate | Excellent |
| Brittleness | Lower | Higher (in pure WC form) |
| Typical Uses | Filaments, electrodes, shielding | Cutting tools, dies, wear parts |
Tungsten and tungsten carbide are not the same material. Tungsten is a single metallic element, and tungsten carbide is a hard alloy formed by the combination of tungsten and carbon. Their connection lies in the fact that they both contain tungsten and are renowned for their hardness and durability. The differences lie in performance and application directions.
- Tungsten: High melting point and high density, suitable for high-temperature and protective scenarios.
- Tungsten carbide: Extremely high hardness, wear-resistant, suitable for processing and impact-resistant applications.
Understanding the differences between the two can not only help you choose the right materials but also prevent you from falling into misunderstandings during procurement or use. The next time you see “tungsten” and “tungsten carbide”, you won’t hesitate whether they are the same or not, but will be able to make a more suitable choice based on your needs.
Related Products
